Our Service Areas

Medicare Agent in Paducah, KY

Paducah has two big hospitals. In 2027, some Medicare Advantage plans could cover neither.

Western Kentucky’s healthcare runs through two regional hospitals on opposite sides of town: Baptist Health Paducah and Mercy Health Lourdes Hospital. Most Medicare Advantage plans only work well if they include at least one of them. For 2027, that’s getting harder:

  • Baptist Health has been out of network for UnitedHealthcare and Wellcare Medicare Advantage since January 2024.
  • Mercy Health says its contract with UnitedHealthcare ends December 31, 2026. Without a new deal, Mercy hospitals and doctors in Ohio and Kentucky, including Lourdes, will be out of network for UHC members starting January 1, 2027.

If you’re on a UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage plan in McCracken County, you could start 2027 with no in-network hospital in Paducah.

Kentucky Medicare Help is an independent agency run by Jeff and Suzanne Janosick. We’ll check your doctors at Baptist, Mercy, and anywhere else you go, and show you which 2027 plans keep them covered. It costs you nothing.

Compare Multiple Kentucky Insurance Companies

No Cost Medicare Supplement Review

Paducah's Hospital Networks at a Glance

 

Baptist Health Paducah

Mercy Health Lourdes

Original Medicare + any Supplement

✅ In network

✅ In network

UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage

❌ Out (since 2024)

⚠️ Contract ends Dec 31, 2026

Wellcare Medicare Advantage

❌ Out (since 2024)

Check your plan

Devoted and Essence Medicare Advantage

❌ Listed as out of network

Check your plan

Humana Medicare Advantage

✅ Listed as in network

Check your plan

Anthem Medicare Advantage

✅ Listed as in network

✅ Listed as accepted

Aetna Medicare Advantage

⚠️ Verify (see note)

✅ Listed as accepted

Based on each hospital’s published insurance lists, which both say are subject to change. We confirm your exact plan and doctors before you enroll.

What this means: if you want both Paducah hospitals available, your realistic choices are Original Medicare with a Medicare Supplement, or a Medicare Advantage plan from a carrier both hospitals accept. Networks are set plan by plan, so you need to check the specific plan, not just the company.

If You Have UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage

Before December 31, nothing changes. Keep your appointments.

Your 2027 decision is due December 7. You can:

  1. Switch now to a plan that includes the hospital and doctors you use. This is the safest option.
  2. Stay with UHC and wait on the Mercy negotiations. If they fail, you can make one change during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 – March 31), but you could be out of network at Lourdes in the meantime, and Baptist is already out.
  3. Move to Original Medicare and a Supplement, which works at both hospitals and at any Medicare provider in the country, including Vanderbilt in Nashville or specialists in St. Louis.

In active treatment at Lourdes? Mercy says some patients with chronic or complex conditions may qualify for Continuity of Care protections. Call UHC at the number on your card to ask.

Schedule a Free Review

Why Medicare Supplements Are So Popular in Paducah

Only about 48% of McCracken County’s Medicare beneficiaries are on Medicare Advantage, compared with about 55% statewide. A lot of Paducah retirees already figured out that with two competing hospital systems, a Supplement is the simplest way to keep both.

Kentucky makes Supplements even better:

  • The Kentucky birthday rule lets you switch to the same plan letter with any company within 60 days after your birthday, with no health questions. You can shop your rate every year.
  • Plan G is the most popular choice in Kentucky. You pay the $283 Part B deductible (2026), and the plan covers nearly everything after that.
  • If your Advantage plan is ending, you likely have a guaranteed right to buy a Supplement with no health questions.

 

Kentucky Medicare Supplement plans explained · How the birthday rule works

McCracken County Plan Changes for 2027

  • 60 Advantage plans are offered for 2027 (up from 56), and 12 are new, including six new Devoted Health plans entering Kentucky. Baptist currently lists Devoted as out of network, so check before you join one for the $0 premium.
  • Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO) H5521-260 is discontinued. About 140 McCracken County members need a new plan.

Being replaced (moved automatically):

Your 2026 plan

Moving to

Members (approx.)

Humana USAA Honor Giveback with Rx (PPO) H7617-005

Humana Essentials Plus Giveback (PPO)

320

Humana USAA Honor Giveback with Rx (PPO) H5216-396

HumanaChoice Giveback H5216-322 (PPO)

250

Humana Gold Plus H5619-071 (HMO)

Humana Gold Plus H5619-188 (HMO)

220

UHC Dual Complete KY-S002 / KY-S4 (D-SNP)

Other UHC Dual Complete plans

300

Veterans, heads up: both Humana USAA plans move members into plans that aren’t veteran-branded and have a $9,850 out-of-pocket maximum (the highest allowed) for 2027. Check your Annual Notice of Change.

UHC Dual members, a double hit: your plan is changing and Mercy’s UHC contract is ending. If you have Medicare and Medicaid, you’ll keep Medicaid, but talk to us before January.

Schedule a Free Review

McCracken County Medicare at a Glance

  • About 17,300 people are on Medicare in McCracken County.
  • About 900 residents turn 65 each year.
  • About 2,600 qualify for both Medicare and Medicaid.
  • Both Paducah hospitals are regional referral centers for western Kentucky, southern Illinois, southeast Missouri, and northwest Tennessee, which makes Paducah the healthcare hub for the whole Jackson Purchase.
Schedule a Free Review

Turning 65 in Paducah

  • Initial Enrollment: 7 months, starting 3 months before your 65th birthday month.
  • Medigap Open Enrollment: a one-time 6-month window after Part B starts, when any Supplement company has to accept you. Turning 65 in Kentucky
  • 2026 costs: the Part B premium is $202.90/month and the deductible is $283.
  • Retiring from a local employer? If you’re on a group plan at an employer with 20+ employees, you can usually delay Part B without a penalty. We’ll check first.
Learn More About Supplement Plans

Areas We Serve in Western Kentucky

Paducah, Lone Oak, Reidland, Hendron, West Paducah, Mayfield, Benton, Calvert City, Murray, Smithland, Wickliffe, and La Center. From downtown along the riverfront to Kentucky Lake, we meet by phone, by video, or in person by appointment.

More help: Kentucky plans ending in 2027 · Owensboro · Elizabethtown · Lexington

Common Questions

Paducah Medicare FAQs

Does Baptist Health Paducah take UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage?

No. Baptist Health has been out of network with UnitedHealthcare and Wellcare Medicare Advantage plans since January 1, 2024. Original Medicare and all Medicare Supplements are accepted.

Mercy Health says its contract with UnitedHealthcare ends December 31, 2026. If no agreement is reached, Mercy hospitals and doctors in Ohio and Kentucky, including Lourdes, will be out of network for UHC members starting January 1, 2027. Both sides say they're still negotiating.

Original Medicare with a Medicare Supplement works at both. Some Medicare Advantage plans include both, but it depends on the specific plan. We'll check before you enroll.

Maybe, if your doctors are in network. Baptist Health currently lists Devoted Medicare Advantage as out of network. We'll check your doctors at both hospitals first.

Check your Annual Notice of Change for your new plan's out-of-pocket maximum. Both Humana USAA plans with drug coverage in McCracken County move to plans with a $9,850 maximum for 2027. Compare before December 7.

No. Our help is free. Insurance companies pay us, and your premium is the same either way.

Get Started

Keep Your Hospital in 2027

Bring your plan letter, your doctor list, and your prescriptions. In 30 minutes we'll show you which 2027 plans keep Baptist, Lourdes, or both in network.